Technology

Best Strategy Board Games for 2023


$138 at Amazon

A field of miniature Star War figures in a fight scene

Star Wars: Shatterpoint

Best strategy game using miniatures

$54 at Amazon

screen-shot-2020-12-03-at-3-05-47-pm.png

Twilight Struggle

Best 2-player strategy board game

Whether you want to play fun family games, cooperative games or even single-player games where the other side is automated, there’s a board game for everyone. These games come in every shape, size and type imaginable. My personal favorites are those games that go a little deeper — the ones that pit you against other players and make you think, not just one move ahead, but two or three. These games are often referred to as strategy games.

What’s the best strategy board game?

Because of the variety, it’s hard to pick one best strategy game, but I do really like Windward right now. It’s only been around for a little while, but it’s a firm favorite at our gaming table. With plenty of strategic choices, a striking board and counters, and a shallow learning curve, it’s the best place to start if you’re trying to decide what to play.

But isn’t every game a strategy game?

Strategy board games are games in which players’ critical decision-making affects the outcome. That’s a pretty broad definition, I know, but modern strategy games come in all sorts of subgenres, often delineated by their central gameplay mechanic: 

Many times, these games are organized into larger categories, such as wargames (which center on a conflict between players’ forces), American-style (which prioritizes direct player conflict and has elements of luck) or Eurogames (which largely avoid chance-based elements and usually depend on planning and resource management).

The most important element of strategy board games, though, is, you guessed it, strategy. While there may be small instances where luck plays a part, the overwhelming mechanics of the game need to rely on the player’s ability to think strategically and to outmaneuver the other players on the board. 

Despite all the games on the market, few have the perfect balance of replayability and satisfying gameplay, even if you lose. So after testing dozens of the best games on the market, I’ve put together the best strategy games available.

The best strategy board games

A round board game with space whales!

James Bricknell/CNET

Windward isn’t as heavy as some of the games on this list but has garnered a lot of love since its release. You play a boat captain who sails the skies of a planet looking to capture giant space whales called Crestors. There is a small amount of luck in the amount of damage you take, but because the wind direction controls your movement, there’s a lot of strategy around how you move and making sure you don’t encounter other players.

My gaming table enjoys Windward as our first strategy game of the night, as it’s relatively light but gets you in the mood for something deeper.

Pros:

  • Lightweight
  • Lots of forward thinking involved
  • Beautiful art

Cons:

  • Too light for deep strategists

A field of miniature Star War figures in a fight scene

Atomic Mass Games

Star Wars: Shatterpoint takes all of your favorite characters from the Clone Wars era and beyond, drops them into a classic squad-based tabletop combat experience, and lets your imagination do the rest of the work. Miniatures are available in simple-to-assemble kits with very little guidance needed, and each can be painted to your personal taste with relative ease. Like the miniatures, the rules of the game do a pretty good job balancing a low learning curve and the flexibility to vary play styles to avoid feeling repetitive. Whether you’re new to the world of tabletop miniatures or a veteran of this classic game style, there’s plenty to like about this game.

Pros:

  • Easy-to-assemble minis
  • Tons of characters available, given how new the game is
  • Excellent starter kit to introduce players to Shatterpoint

Cons:

  • Significant time investment before you can start playing
  • Replacing broken pieces is difficult right now

red and yellow pieces on a tiled board with space and planets

David Priest/CNET

In Gaia Project, players seek to expand their alien race’s control over a galaxy, making planets habitable to their race, building structures on them, gaining knowledge and furthering research. This strategic board game has a fairly steep learning curve for those unfamiliar with Eurogames, but once you get into your first game, you’ll understand the basics within a round or two. But the strategy is deep: You can play as a dozen different races, with unique abilities and research bonuses; the modular board means the galaxy you’re colonizing never looks the same; and many of the scoring and construction bonuses are randomized each game, so the same strategy won’t win every time. Gaia Project is a masterclass in game design and a complete joy to play.

Pros:

  • Deep strategy
  • Huge amount of replayability

Cons:

You’re receiving price alerts for Gaia Project

img-2088

David Priest/CNET

Small World is one of my favorites, simply because this conquest game feels so different every time you play it. Essentially, players are vying for control of a Risk-like board with too few spaces to accommodate everyone, hence the name. You bid for one of dozens of fantastical creatures, each randomly paired with an additional special ability — which can lead to hilarious combinations like Were-Will-o’-the-Wisps or Peace-loving Homunculi. Then you spread using your special abilities, collect coins based on the territory you control and leave that race behind for a new one. It’s an addictive gameplay loop, often equal parts funny and competitive, and you can learn and play it in under two hours.

Pros:

  • Infinite replayability
  • Lighthearted yet strategic
  • Easy to learn

Cons:

screen-shot-2020-12-03-at-3-05-47-pm.png

David Priest/CNET

Twilight Struggle, set during the Cold War, balances the strategic complexity of a “big” game with the simple mechanics of a traditional conquest game like Risk. One player takes the role of the US, and the other plays as the USSR as you struggle for presence, domination or complete control of various battleground regions around the world. Both sides race to put a man on the moon, degrade the DEFCON status through military operations, while carefully avoiding the devastation of nuclear war (an instant loss) and spread their influence across the globe in a tug of war for global power.

Pros:

  • Tense gameplay
  • Topical
  • Well balanced

Cons:

  • A little bland aesthetically 

You’re receiving price alerts for Twilight Struggle

screen-shot-2020-12-11-at-12-47-35-pm.png

Mayfair Games

Agricola is one of the best board games ever designed, and it’s one of the best examples of worker placement mechanics, too. The concept is simple: Players each use their farmer and wife (both called “workers”) to complete various actions as the seasons progress, such as gathering wood or vegetables, upgrading their farm house, building pens, buying animals, having children and much more. Over time, players have children (more workers to use) and expand their farm. The problem during all this, though, is scarcity: Agricola is a harsh game. Even without an opponent blocking you from certain actions, it often feels like you’re just scraping by — getting just enough food to feed your family for the winter. Players often end up with very few (or negative) points in their first game, but when you start to learn, it feels incredibly satisfying.

Pros:

  • Great worker placement game
  • Strategy is everything

Cons:

  • Feels defeatist until you get better!

You’re receiving price alerts for Agricola

screen-shot-2020-12-11-at-12-50-47-pm.png

Ravensburger

Many of the best strategy games take a couple of hours to play, but satisfying strategy need not take all day: The Castles of Burgundy is a perfect example of a great game that usually only takes about an hour to play — often less, once you know how to play — and is surprisingly replayable. Each turn, players roll dice, the numbers on which allow them to pick up certain land tiles from a central board or place them on certain spaces on your player board as you expand your kingdom. The central rules can be learned in a matter of minutes, compared to some of the larger Eurogames above, but Castles of Burgundy will keep you making tough choices about how to respond to a dice roll that’s out of your control.

Pros:

  • Fast gameplay
  • Easy to learn

Cons:

  • More luck than some might like

You’re receiving price alerts for The Castles of Burgundy

screen-shot-2020-12-11-at-12-53-04-pm.png

Splotter

If you have a full day and want to play a long, rewarding game, you can’t do better than Food Chain Magnate — an incredibly deep game of building and staffing restaurants, designing menus, paying for advertisements and collecting money. What makes Food Chain Magnate so enjoyable is the sheer scope of it: You can hire dozens of different kinds of employees, sell dozens of different kinds of food and use half a dozen types of ads, all with unique effects on your franchise, the customers in the city and your opponents. This fun game is an investment, especially if you get the expansions, but it’s one of the most enjoyable and unique takes on the strategy board game format in years.

Pros:

  • Crazy fun
  • A full day of playing

Cons:

  • Pricey if you get all the expansions

You’re receiving price alerts for Food Chain Magnate

screen-shot-2020-12-11-at-12-57-45-pm.png

David Priest/CNET

Star Wars: Imperial Assault largely avoids the roleplaying elements of dungeon crawlers like Gloomhaven, opting instead for solid combat mechanics that pit the Imperial player against the Rebel players. While different missions have different setups — the modular board keeps things fresh — players will get better as they understand the bonuses of certain groups, the ways they can play off their allies and the decisions of when to find cover and when to charge into battle.

Pros:

  • Combat-heavy
  • Great replay value

Cons:

You’re receiving price alerts for Star Wars: Imperial Assault

screen-shot-2020-12-11-at-12-41-22-pm.png

David Priest/CNET

Conquest games have come a long way since Risk, and one of the best is Rising Sun — a game in which players vie for control over the various regions of feudal Japan, using their samurai and other miniatures to spread. What makes the game interesting is the untraditional means and ends of conflict: Alliances lend opponents more power, but betrayals can damage your honor; points can be won by winning in battle, but committing ritual suicide, taking hostages and employing historians to write off your warrior’s honor can actually net you a larger victory. 

What could be a straightforward game about conquering regions becomes about the development of your clan, preservation of their honor and strategic partnerships with your enemies. If you want a game with tons of conflict — but where that conflict is rarely straightforward or obvious — Rising Sun is a perfect game for you.

Pros:

  • Beautiful setting
  • Fun alliance mechanic

Cons:

  • Can be a little confusing

You’re receiving price alerts for Rising Sun

Other strategy games we’ve tested

For good introductions to modern strategy games, I would be remiss not to mention Settlers of Catan and Carcassonne. While most people who catch the board game bug quickly move past these more basic economy and tile-laying games, they are great ways for people to be introduced to the genre.

How we test Strategy Board Games

As you can imagine board game testing is a grueling and often stressful experience. I’m kidding; testing board games is awesome. It is, however, subjective in a lot of ways. I tend to look at certain criteria as to what makes a board game “good, however.”

  • Is the board and piece quality good?
  • Are the instructions clear?
  • How long does it take different age groups to learn?
  • How long does the game take to play?
  • How fun is it? (This is incredibly important)
  • Can you replay it and it still feel fresh?

Because board gaming is a team sport, my family’s opinions are used to help me average out testing. While I may like a 5-hour-long game with 1,000 pieces, my 17-year-old son may not feel the same. Getting a good spread of opinions helps me find the best overall games in each category.